Comparing dead man’s switch services: the four shapes
Four different products wear the same label. What actually separates them, which one suits which problem, and where we sit,…
A dead man’s switch is a device that does something when the person operating it lets go. Train drivers have had them since the nineteenth century: the driver holds a lever, and if they release it — because they have fallen ill, or worse — the brakes come on by themselves. The switch does not detect danger. It has no opinion about the driver’s health. It detects one thing only: the absence of a hand.
Every digital version of the idea works the same way. Something is set to happen. You keep postponing it. If you stop postponing it, it happens.
Strip away the branding and every implementation has the same four parts.
You arm it, and a countdown starts. Every check in resets the countdown. If the countdown ever reaches zero, the payload is delivered and the switch is spent.
That is the whole mechanism. There is no judgement in it, no attempt to work out whether you are actually in trouble, and no human deciding whether today is the day. The only question it ever asks is whether you checked in before the deadline.
Beyond the four parts, the differences between a well-built switch and a crude one come down to a handful of things:
The stereotype is the whistleblower with an insurance file. That does happen, but it is a tiny fraction of real use. The people who set these up are, overwhelmingly, ordinary people solving an ordinary problem: there is something only they know, and no sensible way to hand it over in advance.
By far the most common case. Passwords, the phone PIN, where the documents are, which accounts exist, who to call, what to do with the business. It is not a will and does not try to be — it is the instruction sheet that makes a will possible to act on. See what actually happens to accounts when nobody has made arrangements.
A switch with a three or seven day timer, sending “something is wrong, please check on me” to a friend, is a quiet answer to a real fear. It costs one button press a week and it means somebody would notice.
Solo hikers, sailors, people working in difficult places, people with a medical condition that could go wrong quickly. Often armed for a specific window and paused again on return.
Here the switch is not about death, it is about disappearance. Material held by one person and released automatically if that person goes quiet. This is the dramatic case and it is real, but it is not the common one.
Sometimes the payload is not data at all. It is a letter that was never going to be sent while the writer could still speak.
An honest article has to include this section.
It is not an emergency service. If your timer is seven days and something happens on day one, nothing is sent for six more days. If you need someone alerted in minutes, you need a person with your phone number, or a medical alert device, not this.
It is not a will. Delivering instructions to a named person confers no legal authority on them. Use it to make a will easy to act on, not to replace one.
It is not a substitute for telling people things. If you can have the conversation now, have it now. A switch is for what cannot be said in advance, not for what you would rather avoid saying.
It does not suit an unstructured life, at short intervals. A one-day timer is a promise to press a button every day for the rest of your life, including the day the phone dies and the weekend with no signal.
If you take one practical point from this article, take this one.
The interval is not a measure of how urgent your secret is. It is a measure of how reliably you can press a button. People set a short timer because the contents feel important, and then they trigger it by accident within a month, on an ordinary Tuesday, to a recipient who has no idea what is going on.
The rule that works: take the longest realistic stretch you might go without reliable internet — a flight, a hospital stay, a camping trip, a genuinely awful week — and double it. That is your minimum safe interval.
For the classic estate case, thirty days is right. Nothing about “here is how to reach my accounts” becomes useless because it arrives three weeks later, and a monthly check in is a habit you can keep for years. Run a second, shorter vault if you also want someone alerted quickly. There is no rule that everything lives on one timer, and this is covered properly in the help centre.
A fair question and you should ask it of any provider. The mitigation is not to trust a promise; it is not to make any single arrangement the only one. Keep a paper copy of the critical recovery path somewhere safe as well. A deadman switch should be the thing that delivers your plan reliably, not the only place your plan exists.
Then a letter arrives early, and you make an awkward phone call. This is why warnings, pausing and a sensible interval matter, and why the shortest interval on a serious vault should be measured in weeks rather than hours.
Ask. And be suspicious of a service that answers this too smoothly. Any switch that can email an attachment to someone with no account and no key must be able to decrypt on your behalf, which means the honest answer is never “nobody could ever read this”. Ours is that files are encrypted with AES-256-GCM and the keys are themselves encrypted, which defeats every realistic attack on data at rest — a stolen bucket, a leaked backup, a compromised host — but decryption happens on our server at the moment of delivery. If you need a stronger guarantee than that, encrypt the file yourself before uploading it and give your recipient the passphrase another way. We set out the whole position in how your files are encrypted.
Fifteen minutes, once, and then a minute a month.
A dead man’s switch is a simple idea with a grim name and a mundane, useful purpose: it makes sure something gets said if you are not there to say it. Most people who use one are not protecting a secret. They are sparing somebody six months of phone calls.
My Signal Vault is a dead man’s switch with encrypted file storage attached. The free plan gives you one vault, 100MB of encrypted storage and the full audit log, with no card and no expiry. If you would rather understand the mechanism first, the help centre covers all of it, and our guide to choosing a service lists the questions worth asking of anyone, including us.
The Free plan gives you one vault and 100MB of encrypted storage. No card, no expiry.
Create a free vaultAsk me how vaults work, what happens when a timer runs out, or which plan fits. For anything about your own account, use the contact form and a person will reply.